FANDOM


Proposed quote change Edit

Given recent edits, I'm opening a discussion to talk about changing the quote on the article. User:Sasha Taymasov desires to change the quote on the article to:

Sam? (...) Sam... (...) What have you done? (...) Sa... Sa... Sam... (...) It's your fault... (...) It's all your fault...
— Henry's last words to Joel's Fault for Sam's fate and before committing suicide.

from the current quote:

You had a good chance of making it, and you did. But coming back for you meant putting [Sam] at risk. If it was the other way around, would you have come back for us? I saved you.
— Henry persuading Joel not to shoot him

Personally, I am against the change as the one we already have displays much more about Henry's character namely: He's protective of Sam, is brave enough to stand up to Joel, prioritizes his brother's safety over Joel and Ellie, is rather persuasive, is quick thinking and also displays his good nature in (despite abandoning Joel) ultimately chose to save his life rather than let him drown. Snivystorm (talk) 09:18, June 15, 2018 (UTC)

I agree with Snivystorm, the quote we had before more accurately showed Henry's personality and outlook on life. We could always put the other quote in the article, just farther down. M67PattonZippo (talk) 10:58, June 15, 2018 (UTC)
Indeed, we already have a quotes section on other pages (like Joel and Ellie's) so there's no harm adding one here if need be. Snivystorm (talk) 11:15, June 15, 2018 (UTC)

Given seven says have passed and no further discussion has taken place, the verdict stands that the quote we have already shall remain the key quote on the page. This discussion is now closed.

Verdict: Quote remains as is. Snivystorm (talk) 18:22, June 22, 2018 (UTC)